Prof. Dr. Christofer Lenz and Dr. Maximilian Gerhold successfully represented the Ministry of the Interior, Digitalisation and Europe of Baden-Württemberg in urgent proceedings brought by the Berlin branch of the political party DIE LINKE before the Stuttgart Administrative Court.
The case concerned remarks made by Manuel Hagel in an interview with BILD about potential coalition options in Berlin involving DIE LINKE. Referring to the party’s lead candidate in the Berlin House of Representatives election, Mr Hagel used the expression “left-wing clan mayor”. The remarks attracted considerable media attention.
DIE LINKE’s Berlin branch claimed that the remarks infringed its constitutional right to equal opportunities in political competition under Article 21 of the German Basic Law. It applied for interim relief requiring the State of Baden-Württemberg to refrain from making comparable statements.
The Court’s First Chamber accepted OPPENLÄNDER’s submissions. It held that Mr Hagel had spoken in his capacity as a party politician and State Chair of the CDU, rather than in his official roles as Minister of the Interior and Deputy Minister-President. The heightened duties of neutrality and objectivity governing statements made by public office holders therefore did not apply. Instead, the remarks fell within the scope of freedom of expression and could not be attributed to the State of Baden-Württemberg. The application was accordingly dismissed by order of 21 October 2026 (Case No. 1 K 10629/26).
OPPENLÄNDER regularly represents constitutional bodies and state ministries in proceedings before German constitutional and administrative courts.
Selected media coverage of our successful representation of the State of Baden-Württemberg: